What Went Wrong With Muslims?

Photo: Shailendra Pandey
Photo: Shailendra Pandey

In 1770 the Turkish naval establishment was wiped out at the Battle of Çeşme (on the coast of the Mediterranean Sea) by a Russian fleet. In 1799, the Fourth Mysore War was fought between Tipu Sultan and the British East India Company at Srirangapatanam. In this war, Tipu Sultan was killed. When the Governor- General, George Harris, heard of the death of Tipu Sultan, he is said to have exclaimed: “Today, India is ours!”

These two events symbolise the beginning of the end of Muslim political glory in the modern age. There were a series of such events everywhere in Muslim countries and the Muslim leadership of that time strongly reacted to this disturbing phenomenon. But history shows that in all their attempts they totally failed to achieve their goal. First, there were complaints, then protests, followed by violence, then the gun culture, and, lastly, suicide bombing. In short, this is the scenario of more than two hundred years of Muslim struggle. What is happening in Egypt today is only the latest manifestation of this unsuccessful Muslim activism.

Now the time has come to reassess this long failed struggle. There is no justification for continuing this pattern of resistance. That will only lead to more losses. An unbiased study tells us that the Western powers whom Muslims considered enemies were, in fact, not enemies, but harbingers of a new civilisation. It was the Western nations who had developed this new civilisation and it was bound to spread out across the world. But there were two aspects to this. One was the political dominance of Western nations. And the other was that they had brought to the world an age of new science, technology and industry. The traditional world was then transformed into a new world, which resulted in a change in the balance of power.

The mistake that Muslim leaders made was that they failed to understand this duality. They took it as simply a political phenomenon and they waged a political war against these Western nations. In this situation, the best policy for Muslims would have been to differentiate between politics and civilisation. The better choice would have been to avoid the political problem and take into account the non-political aspect of Western expansion, that is, the civilisation ushered in by the West, based on scientific discoveries and modern technology.

It was this policy that was adopted by the Japanese after the Second World War, and within less than fifty years they emerged as an economic superpower. The same option was opened up for the Muslim nations. They should have avoided the political problem and availed of the civilisational opportunities instead. Had the Muslims done this, history would have taken a different course. Instead of being a protesting community, Muslims would have emerged as a successful community globally.

This creative policy is definitely an Islamic policy and the Prophet of Islam adopted it. During the negotiations prior to the signing of the Hudaybiyah Treaty (a treaty between Prophet Muhammad, representing the state of Medina, and the Quraish tribe of Mecca, which helped to decrease tension between the two cities, affirmed a 10-year peace, and authorized Muhammad’s followers to return the following year in a peaceful pilgrimage), he avoided political problems and tried to avail of whatever opportunities presented themselves at that time. Thus he went on to have that great success that is mentioned in the Quran as a ‘clear victory’ (48:1).

Here I would like to refer to two verses from the Quran. The first reads, “O Believers, turn you all together towards God.” (24:31). In this verse, the Arabic word used for turning to God in repentance is tawbah (tubu ilallah). Tawbah means, in a sense, following a U-turn policy, which means to re-assess one’s actions and make amends. In the context of this verse, it means that Muslims must adopt such a policy at the level of the entire community. The other Quranic verse tells us, “God does not change that which is with a people until they change that which is with themselves.” (13:11). This means that if Muslims want to see a new future, they must change their present.

Now, in the twenty-first century, the time has come for Muslims to adopt a U-turn. They must bring to an end all violent activities and should devote their energies to achieving a two-point formula of education and dawah, reaching out with God’s message. Education will bring their succeeding generations into line with modern standards, and dawah work will provide them with a global mission through which they will be able to chalk out a proper line of action for themselves.

(The views expressed in this column are the writer’s own)


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment may take some time to appear.