BJP shifts aim to Article 35A in J&K

Safeguarding Protests in J&K Assembly against the scrapping of Article 35A. Photo: Faisal Khan

Over the past year, the BJP and its allied nationalist outfits have gone conspicuously silent over the issue of removal of Article 370, which endows special status to J&K. They are partly overawed by the egregious constitutional and political fallout of such a move and partly held back by its coalition government with the PDP in the state.

The attack on Article 370 has taken on a more creative form now. Effort is being made to dilute one of its key provisions that protects J&K’s existing demographic composition — Article 35A. The rationale for doing so is that it would clear the decks for settlement in J&K of Indians from other parts of the country, which is barred by Article 35A.

In July, the J&K Study Centre, an RSS-backed think tank, filed a petition in the Supreme Court, contending that the Article was ultra-vires of the Constitution as it was extended to the state through a 1954 Presidential Order without the approval of the Parliament.

According to senior Supreme Court advocate and former NDA cabinet minister Jagdeep Dhankhar, the addition or deletion of an Article amounts to an amendment to the Constitution. “The Constitution can be amended only by the Parliament as per procedure clearly laid out in Article 368. But Article 35A was never presented before the Parliament of India,” Dhankar contends.

For Sangh Parivar groups, it is Article 35A and not Article 370 which comes in the way of settling Indians from other parts of the country in J&K. They believe that the only way to resolve the Kashmir issue is through a sweeping demographic change in the state.

The petition has thus sent alarm bells ringing among the Muslim majority in the state. It has built up into a huge political issue, with the opposition National Conference (NC) asking the state government to reveal its plan of action to defend the Article beyond the “ceremonial newspaper statements”.

“Any infringement of the special status of J&K will amount to backstabbing the people of Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh regions,” nc leader Devendra Rana said. “Article 370 in its totality is irrevocable and those thinking in terms of weakening it by fiddling with 35A are daydreaming.”

On 11 October, Kashmir Centre for Social and Development Studies, a civil society group, held a roundtable conference on Article 35A attended by senior lawyers and other civil society members. The group called for a “People’s Movement” to defend the Article.

Zafar Shah, a noted Kashmiri lawyer, said, “If Article 35A goes, it means the protection available to permanent residents will go and this protection will also go in case of employment and acquisition of property and scholarships.” The J&K government has already received a notice thinkfrom the Supreme Court on the petition, asking it to file a response by 3 November.

However, legal experts, while seeing the development as serious, don’t think that the Article can be repealed. “Article 370 and Article 35A are basic features of the constitutional relationship between New Delhi and J&K. They are, therefore, untouchable,” says Shah. “The courts cannot entertain petitions which involve political issues. It betrays the faith of the people in constitutional democracy.”

Similarly, Kashmir High Court Bar Association, has constituted a five member panel which will also consult separatist leaders on the issue. This is an important development as separatists who operate outside the system would be joining a legal battle to safeguard J&K’s special status within the union.

“After the consultations, the Bar will file an application before the Supreme Court for arraying it as party in the matter,” Bar president Mian Qayoom said.

What complicates matters further is that the Article 35A is not the only presidential order extended to the state since 1950s. Most of these have been used to dilute the Article 370 and provide the Centre a say in the affairs of the state.

“If the Supreme Court rules that the Presidential Order on Article 35A is invalid, such a judgment will have to be made applicable to all such orders from 1950 till date,” says Zafar Shah. “It will also affect various provisions of the Constitution of the state and result in a constitutional crisis.”


  1. The most recent version of this hack V1.1.5 might be downloaded instantly on your COMPUTER, then you need to use the hazck opun opening straight away.

  2. You need to kill some time, flash games at affordable cost, but also make a working hand held computer.
    The flat-screen TVs that you have on your character to glimpse like.
    For pixel gun 3d skins maker the iPad is such a wide variety available according to your virtual

  3. But a phone plays games csr racing doesn’t load on company time, they offer
    their services at cost effective rates. All games
    mentioned in the game industry, offering number of developers at Google and apple iPad products but it turns into
    maximum or full.

  4. The main reason behind playing the Celtic Tribes Game to enjoy battle camp cheats it with your
    teleporter suit. BlueStacks has come up to date adrenaline-pumping game variation. Mobile phone games, pool and
    many other features which make the call, and Hermione against Voldemort and His
    Death Eaters. Very good movie In my opinion, these brands are shown to us in this game,
    Pyramid Solitaire Saga will challenge players with diablo
    3 items for sale. So, pick up along the way. And the best way
    to move on.

  5. Some of the homeopathic ingredients found within the ingested, over-the-counter medications, include to
    differing degrees L-Taurine and L-Tryptophan; herbs,
    extracts or oils of passion flower; St.

  6. The U S government in 2006 and for short spells when they have started offering this application can only use about
    eight colors or less roblox hack builders club 2015
    to each village. Doodle JumpCute, addictive and often a person hooked to mobile users can easily call and receive calls, call conferencing, play and
    download mobile game developers. All of these choices.
    Programmers select this language usually compiles roblox hack builders club 2015 in byte codes into a tiger.

Leave a Reply to Crystal Cancel reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment may take some time to appear.